Wednesday, 18 November 2026

How Germany views great power relationship?

There are three types of powers: great power, middle power and small power. There are three major countries besotting the great power realm: USA, Russia and China. Let me give you a broad eye-view of German relationship with these three nations using the anchor of geoeconomics:

Basics

Relationship generally covers politics, economics and military in the primary sector and society, technology and geography in the secondary sector. In strategy these vectors are vitally important. When a specific area is selected by say, Germany to make her presence felt it gains a prefix “Geo”. Hence in the case of economics it is calibrated as “geoeconomics”. My forte is geoeconomics strategy. Here are few snippets of my take on German geoeconomics visa-vis America - Russia - China.

America

After the defeat of Germany in WWII, the Marshall Plan was unveiled where America went on a lend-lease program for developing the war ravaged German economy. Do not, for a moment assume that it is a charitable act. The cold War has already started and America has to wean away Germany from the clutches of resource rich Soviet Union. By the way, Germany is resource hungry throughout her history since inauguration of German Empire in 1871.

Therefore, USA opted for a Parent–Child relationship. After the flow of funds into German coffers America widened the net to cover security umbrella over West Europe after unveiling NATO.  Germany was turned into an economic power house supplying finished goods using US Technology and providing US domestic market.

Russia

The Soviet Union continued the business as usual in supplying cheap energy to power the industrial hegemon of Germany. Pipelines carrying energy into Germany was only the tip of the iceberg. Underneath lies the century old marvel Russia had of the Germany since the Great Peter times. The mutual benefit evolved into adult–adult relationship. It resulted in fairly balanced view of each other. In terms of cash-flow, Germans helped pay for the colossal Russian import bills!

China

Originally beginning as Parent–Child, phenomenon in the reverse order to that of US-German relationship, it blossomed into an unbalanced geoeconomics situation today where Germany is importing huge quantum of industrial and manufactured goods from China where royalties paid to Germany by China using the latter’s techno skills and -patents is marginal compared to the volume of surplus China amassing at the expense of German industrial power base. Of course, there are German corporates doing well. But that trend is now lessening as China has set out to replace her techno side with cheaper and efficient methods that are being continually evolved. AI is one such area where even NVidia is getting busted.

Strategy Advice

Neither Germany nor America can compete with China in the techno spectrum. So a re-look at the mission, vision, strategy and tactics has to be initiated where multidisciplinary approach must be perfected and adopted.

Hence, navigating strategy amid geoeconomics urges German planners to come out with a novel approach of “means – ways - goals- theorem”.

 

Cheers!

 

Muthu Ashraff

Strategy Adviser

Mobile: + 94 777 265677

E-mail: cosmicgems@gmail.com

Blog:   Strategy Adviser

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

How Germany views great power relationship?

There are three types of powers: great power, middle power and small power. There are three major countries besotting the great power real...